Thursday, April 15, 2010

No More Rubber Rooms

It's hard to believe but for years New York City Public School teachers who were suspended from teaching and awaiting disciplinary hearings were sent to so-called "rubber rooms." These were places where they sat all day, did nothing -- and got paid for it. (As far as I know these rooms weren't literally padded like Supermax prison cells but the tedium of being in them every day was apparently the same).

The teachers exiled to them were often accused of incompetence, sometimes of gross misbehavior, but ,whatever their alleged infraction, union rules made it impossible to fire them. Instead, they had to wait ... and wait ... and wait ... and wait, sometimes for years in these rooms, until they finally got their hearings. Meanwhile they earned their salary and full benefits, costing the taxpayers around $30 million a year. Think of that? $30 million to pay people to do nada.

This is ending. Today the Bloomberg administration announced that the rubber rooms will be no more; instead these teachers will be assigned clerical or other non-classroom jobs. So finally we taxpayers will be paying these semi-laid off teachers to do something productive and stop wasting money. Sounds like a good idea.

These rubber rooms sound almost like these terrorist detention camps: the people in them are basically being warehoused. Some of them clearly should be there while others ... well ... it's not so clear if their imprisonment is really legally justified. They're in limbo.

Last year the veteran journalist Steven Brill did a long story for The New Yorker about the teachers who populate[d] these rubber rooms. It paints a fascinating picture of why unions are good things overall (protecting workers from exploitation, abuse, firing women for getting pregnant, etc.) but how certain union rules can lead to unproductive waste (like rubber rooms). And it's also clear from this article that some these teachers are either just lousy or unfit to educated students.

Sometimes I have to wonder, however, if these rubber rooms were being used for less than noble purposes. Clearly sending teachers there was a form of psychological gamesmanship: the Department of Ed. wanted to make them so unpleasant and boring that hopefully the teachers would just quit. (WNYC did a great story today about life in the rubber rooms.) But the thing that really disturbed me was how teachers who had been teaching for years and years were suddenly declared "incompetent" and banished into these gulags.

Really? A teacher is told that she's doing a fine job for years and then, all of a sudden, is told "Oh, you're no good. Get out." It's odd. Makes no sense. It seems to me that if someone is being told that they're doing a job well for years and then, all of a sudden, they're told that they're a failure and need to leave ... well, something else is going on. I think this is about forcing out older teachers who have accrued high salaries and pensions so that the city doesn't have to pay as much. It's also about, as these stories suggest, new principals who come in, decide they don't like certain teachers, and then suddenly say they're "incompetent" and force them out.

Oh, but that would be being cynical now wouldn't it? And of course the Bloomberg administration never does anything that would make a New Yorker think it would do something sleazy? But at least the rubber rooms are no more ... and that's probably a step in the right direction.

1 comment:

  1. Hi there!
    Sean Needles from Twins Talent here. We are a NY based Casting company, responsible for casting many of your favorite food shows! We are again casting a culinary show and hoping you could help us spread the word to your network of chefs and foodies alike!!! Any help would be appreciated.

    Thanks,
    Sean Needles
    Casting Associate
    ----------------------------
    Lisa & Debbie Ganz
    Casting Directors
    Twinsworld1@aol.com
    917-678-9996

    ======================================================
    We are casting a GREAT NEW SHOW LOOKING FOR CULINARY DYNAMIC DUOS TO HOST THEIR OWN FOOD & TRAVEL SHOW ACROSS AMERICA. (Read to bottom for details)

    YOU NEED TO BE CHARISMATIC, KNOW FOOD, & BE READY TO BUDDY UP FOR THE ULTIMATE FOOD ROAD TRIP OF A LIFETIME!

    You can be friends, rivals, family, dating, WHATEVER! Fun Fun!

    We are auditioning dynamic culinary couples IMMEDIATELY in the Greater NY, NJ, CT, Philly Areas... or anyone willing to come to NY!

    If you live outside the area, or cannot come to NY, please read to bottom for home submission video instructions. Culinary couples from all over are welcome to apply!

    Please respond to: Twinsworld1@aol.com
    Thanks,
    Lisa and Debbie
    www.twinstalent.tv
    =========================================================
    The Search is on for the New Faces of Food!
    CASTING IMMEDIATELY!
    LOOKING FOR DYNAMIC CULINARY DUOS WHO ARE A CUT ABOVE THE REST IN PERSONALITY & TALENT TO STAR & HOST THEIR OWN FOOD RELATED SHOW!
    YOU NEED TO BE CHARISMATIC & READY FOR THE ULTIMATE BUDDY ROAD TRIP FOR FOOD!
    (Must be at least 21 and comfortable on camera to host a brand new, non-competition traveling food series)

    Do you have larger than life, outgoing personalities with a sizzling passion for all things food?
    Do you have a smoking food vocabulary to host?
    Do you both know food and are knowledgeable in food ingredients?
    Are you both a cut above all the rest in personality and talent?
    Can you both star and host your own show for a network?
    Do you have a passion for traveling and new adventures?

    If you both answered yes to these questions & if you have culinary expertise, a broad knowledge of food & the ability to speak intelligently and enthusiastically about food, ingredients and flavor-
    WE WANT TO MEET YOU!

    Calling all food professionals, executive-level chefs, sous chefs, cooks, grill masters, bakers, professional food bloggers, critics, competitive cooking winners, caterers, etc.
    THIS IS YOUR CHANCE TO HOST YOUR OWN SHOW!

    You can be friends, rivals, family, dating, WHATEVER! Above all else the two of you need to be charismatic on the ultimate buddy road trip for food.

    If you are interested in auditioning:
    Email: Twinsworld1@aol.com

    Please include BOTH of your full names, where you live, ages, contact info, culinary experience (professional and/or personal), about your passion for food & travel, photos if available, how the DUO is related to each other or how you know each other , why you think you would be the perfect hosts - do you share the same opinions or are you different? And any other fun info you would like to include about yourselves!
    WE ARE AUDITIONING COUPLES IMMEDIATELY IN THE Greater NY, NJ, Conn, Philly Area
    If you live outside of this area or cannot come to NY, PLEASE VISIT www.FoodHostCasting.com, follow the instructions and make your home submission video immediately
    ===================================================
    ALSO CASTING INDIVIDUAL FOOD HOST: Bold individuals who have all the right ingredients! We are looking for funny, adventurous, larger-than-life personalities with a passion for food, especially eating who are always up for the challenge to try the newest, the biggest, the spiciest and the weirdest culinary curiosities on the planet.
    To be considered for this show, you MUST make a home video submission.
    VISIT: www.FoodHostCasting.com

    ReplyDelete

Please keep it civil, intelligent, and expletive-free. Otherwise, opine away.