Ghosts of the NYPD Past

This blog, and others like it, love to reminisce about the old days in NYC, when the city was cheaper and funkier -- yes, it was much more dirty and dangerous but at least it was more accessible and more vibrant.

So often it feels, when you look at old movies, TV shows, and documentaries about NYC in decades past, that it's like looking through a fun-house mirror at a place that's both near and distance, familiar and foreign, so close and yet so far. And the feeling you get, or at least that I get, is that that NYC, that period in the city's life, whatever it is, whenever it was, is well and truly over -- buried if not forgotten. 

But what if the past isn't fully over, what if the ghosts of decades-old NYC are still haunting us?

Such is the case of a former NYPD cop named Bill Phillips who, in the early 1970s, testified for the Knapp Commission and helped to expose massive corruption in the department. Unlike his contemporary Frank Serpico, a truly honest cop who blew the whistle about his dirty colleagues, Phillips was as dirty as any of them -- but, when he got busted, he agreed to tell the commission everything he knew in exchange for immunity. Lots of corrupt cops got in trouble from his testimony -- and they got their revenge.

According to this fascinating article, a year after Phillips testified, he was charged with a double homicide. He was accused of bribing a hooker and her pimp who weren't, allegedly, paying him their shakedown money. He was convicted and went to prison for decades. But he has maintained his innocence and the evidence it making it clear that he was intentionally framed by his fellow cops. It's a heartbreaking story of an institution meant to protect us but that, like most, is only interested in protecting its own.

To this day, more than 50 years since the murders and more than 50 years since Phillips went to jail, he is fighting to clear to his name (he was released years ago but his conviction stands). He's a very old man now but he's adamant about fighting for his innocence. Even today, half-a-century later, the NYPD is resisting coming clean about this, delaying and denying him justice. Phillips may get exonerated eventually or not but it's reminder that some of the old problems of old NYC haven't gone away -- and that the present NYPD is still very much like the past NYPD.

And it's a reminder that the past in NYC is never fully gone.